Mike Evans and the Underrated NFL Vets You’re Ignoring — And Why That’s a Huge Mistake

Alright, folks, strap in because I’m about to drop some truth bombs on you like an out-of-control linebacker barreling through your fantasy league illusions. The 2025 NFL offseason has been a rollercoaster of shiny new rookies flaunting their gold bling and some veteran players hopping onto new teams like drunken party crashers. But while everyone’s gawking at the flashy newcomers like it’s the Super Bowl halftime show, the real treasures — the unsung, underrated veterans — are quietly lurking, ready to smack your fantasy hopes with some serious points.

These guys aren’t making headlines or starring in ESPN highlight reels, but don’t be fooled. Underestimating them is like skipping leg day at the gym — you think you’re fine, but your whole structure’s about to collapse. So here’s the lowdown on five NFL vets who are the secret sauce to your fantasy success in 2025. Ready to stop being an idiot? Let’s go.

Jared Goff — The Detroit Lions’ Quiet Veteran Maestro

Remember when Jared Goff got traded to the Lions in 2021? Everyone collectively yawned, thinking he was some watered-down Stafford replacement. Well, wake up because Goff has turned into Detroit’s MVP whisperer.

He stumbled out of the gates, sure, which was like watching a dad try to use TikTok (awkward as hell). But since then? The guy’s been cooking like a five-star chef. Three straight top-10 fantasy finishes, a career-high 333.5 fantasy points last year, and locking down the QB6 spot like he owns it. Yet, somehow, fantasy managers still treat him like the lanky kid in gym class nobody picked for dodgeball, drafting him way too late (ADP 85, QB10). I’m screaming from the rooftops — this is your chance to cash in.

Yes, losing offensive coordinator Ben Johnson (he’s off to coach the Bears, apparently chasing another mid-life crisis) sucks. But Goff’s chill about John Morton taking over makes me think the Lions’ offense won’t skip a beat. And with weapons like Jahmyr Gibbs, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Sam LaPorta, and rookie Isaac TeSlaa lined up, this could be Goff’s coming out party. I’m so hyped it’s like watching a turtle suddenly out-sprint a cheetah.

James Conner — The Quiet Consistency Machine of the Cardinals

If fantasy football were a party, James Conner would be the reliable, sturdy friend who shows up early, makes sure the snacks don’t run out, and leaves without drama. No fireworks, just consistent production. Cardinals fans might think he’s old hat, but Conner’s been a top-20 RB all four years in Arizona, finishing 2024 as RB11 despite missing a game.

Sure, rookie Trey Benson is lurking like your little brother wanting your Xbox, but Conner held the fort, bowling over defenders and fantasy managers’ expectations alike. Drafted as the RB21 with an ADP of 68, he’s undervalued like that last slice of pizza no one claims until it’s the only one left. And trust me, you want that slice.

Mike Evans — The Legendary WR Who Refuses to Let Age Define Him

So here’s the deal — Mike Evans is like a fine wine, but not the kind that turns to vinegar after cork popping. He’s more like that magical wizard wine that doesn’t age, doesn’t spoil, just gets better and leaves your opponents dizzy from envy.

Evans has been a beast for the Buccaneers, racking WR4 and WR7 finishes even with Baker Mayfield throwing him the ball. And here’s the kicker — fantasy guys are lowballing him now, drafting him as the WR19? Are you kidding me? The man’s finished outside the top 8 just *once* in seven years, and even that was a respectable WR16. It’s like ignoring the rockstar in your band because you’re envious he’s cooler than you.

His 11 consecutive 1,000-yard seasons are an NFL record. He’s scary consistent, rarely missing games, and relies on hands and smarts over rampant speed. Sure, the loss of offensive coordinator Liam Coen might scare the rookies, but Josh Grizzard (the so-called “wizard” of the Bucs’ offense) steps up to keep the magic flowing. If you’re passing on Mike Evans, you’re digging your own grave.

Terry McLaurin — The Commanders’ Reluctant Superstar

Look, I get it. Washington Commanders were a hot mess for years. Like a group project where everyone hides from the work. Terry McLaurin was stuck collecting dust instead of fantasy glory. But 2024 was his breakout, holding it down as Jayden Daniels’ best bud and ripping off a career-best 82 catches, 1,096 yards, and 13 touchdowns. Turns out, good QB chemistry actually matters, who knew?

Yet, fantasy managers still treat McLaurin like the forgotten kid at dance practice, drafting him as WR17 with an ADP of 29. Seriously? His 76% quality start rate (catching passes like they were on sale) matches the league’s elite, and he’s practically guaranteed to rise with Daniels expected to take a huge step forward in Year 2.

Even Deebo Samuel’s presence hasn’t stolen McLaurin’s thunder. He’s the clear No. 1 target and has the rapport to make every catch count. If you’re sleeping on McLaurin, might as well set your money on a coin flip and call it a day.

Mark Andrews — The Aging Hawk of the Ravens’ Offense

Last but definitely not least, Mark Andrews. He’s on the wrong side of 30 and some fantasy managers already treat him like that guy at the office no one invites to happy hour. But Andrews just shrugged off a rough start in 2024 to deliver his fifth top-six fantasy TE season in six years.

Yeah, his infamous playoff drop still haunts some, but the man finished strong, never dipping below TE7 from Weeks 13-18. That’s more consistency than most of us can muster before lunch. Add in 11 touchdowns and 69 catches, and you’ve got a fine bargain at his ADP of 107 (TE8).

He’s battling injury concerns, sure, but he was healthy last year, and with young Isaiah Likely in tow, the Ravens’ tight end throne isn’t going anywhere. If you hold off on drafting Andrews because of a single botched moment, you deserve to watch your team start their fantasy playoff game with your thumb up your nose.

So there it is. Five vets you need to treat like gold, not leftovers. Because fantasy football isn’t just about chasing shiny new toys — sometimes it’s about holding onto the gritty legends who quietly drop big numbers while everyone else is chasing buzz. Don’t be that guy who misses out because you can’t see past the hype.

Now go forth and draft wisely, you glorious oddballs.